Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

Moderator: T3hGuppy

User avatar
Tomcat64
Brigadier General
Brigadier General
Posts: 7034
Joined: Thu Sep 22, 2016 3:24 pm
Location: Swindon, UK
England

Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

Post by Tomcat64 »

So after a bit of dithering I've finally settled on this for my first entry into this GB - the British Cruiser Tank A34 "Comet"
Image

Here's some background courtesy of Wikipedia, plus some images I've picked up off the web from a variety of sources including the Imperial War Museum
Overview
The Comet tank or Tank, Cruiser, Comet I (A34) was a British cruiser tank that first saw use near the end of World War II during the Invasion of Germany. It was developed from the earlier Cromwell tank and mounted the new 17 pdr High Velocity (HV) (3 inch; 76.2 mm – sometimes referred to as "77 mm") gun, in a lower profile, partly-cast turret. This gun was effective against late-war German tanks, including the Panther at medium range, and the Tiger. The tank was widely respected as one of the best British tanks of the war, and continued in service afterwards.
The Comet, which was a development of the Cromwell, rendered the Challenger obsolete, and led to the development of the Centurion tank. When firing APDS rounds, the 77 mm HV was superior in armour penetration capability to the 75 mm KwK 42 gun of the equivalent Axis tank, the Panther (which did not use APDS ammunition). The Comet saw action in the closing stages of World War II and remained in British service until 1958. In some cases, Comets sold to other countries continued to operate into the 1980s.
Image
Background
Combat experience against the Germans in the Western Desert Campaign demonstrated to the British many shortcomings with their cruiser tanks. Hence a request was made in 1941 for a new heavy cruiser tank that could achieve battle superiority over German models. For reasons of economy and efficiency, it had to use as many components as possible from the current A15 Mk VI Crusader tank.
The initial designs for the new Cromwell tank evolved into the A24 Mk VII Cavalier tank and the A27L Mk VIII Centaur tank, both powered by the Nuffield Liberty. Design progressed through the Mk VII (A27M) Cromwell, a third parallel development to the Cavalier and Centaur, sharing many of the same characteristics.

Under the newer A27M specification, Cromwell integrated a number of advanced features. The Meteor engine proved to be very reliable and gave the tank good mobility but some problems appeared based on the vehicle's shared heritage and significant jump in engine power. The tank was prone to throwing its tracks if track tension was not maintained properly or if it turned at too high a speed or too sharply. There were also some problems with suspension breakage, partly due to the Cromwell's high speed and it ran through a number of design changes as a result.

The biggest complaint was related to firepower; the Cromwell had originally been designed to carry the 57 mm Ordnance QF 6-pounder, also retrofitted to the Crusader tanks. In combat, these were found to be useful against other tanks but lacking any reasonable high explosive load they were ineffective against anti-tank guns or static emplacements. Prior to the Cromwell entering combat service, the Ordnance QF 75 mm was introduced which equipped the majority of Cromwells, an adapted version of the 6-pounder firing shells from the US 75 mm gun from the Sherman. This offered somewhat lower anti-tank performance than the 6-pounder but its much larger shell provided an effective high explosive load.

Several attempts had been made to further improve firepower by fitting a more powerful gun. In parallel with development of the Cromwell and QF 75 mm gun, a new Vickers High Velocity 75 mm tank gun had been designed but this proved too large for the Cromwell turret ring and left a shortage in offensive anti-tank capability. A prior requirement for a 17-pounder armed tank led to development of the A30 Mk VIII Challenger. Based on the Cromwell, the hull had to be lengthened and a much larger turret set on top to allow a second loader for the 17-pounder, a requirement of the older specification believed necessary for the larger ammunition. The very high turret of the Challenger was considered a liability and this led to experiments with the similar A30 Avenger version, an anti-tank version with an open-top turret.

Conversion of Sherman tanks to the Sherman Firefly (a Sherman tank fitted with the 17-pounder gun) was significantly faster than Challenger production and driven by operational needs of the Normandy invasion, production of Challenger was dropped. Fireflies (and the limited number of Challengers) provided additional firepower to Cromwell and Sherman armed troops. One Firefly would be issued to each troop of Cromwells (giving three Cromwells and one Sherman Firefly). Problems were encountered due to the different maintenance requirements and associated supply complication of two tank models, as well as the performance difference between Cromwell and Sherman and the Sherman's silhouette, even larger than the Challenger. The large size and obvious difference of both Challenger and Firefly made them a priority target for Axis forces.

Recognising that a common low profile vehicle was required to replace the mixed fleet of Cromwell, Challenger and Firefly tanks, a new specification of tank was created. This removed the Challenger's need for a second loader and mounted the newer Vickers High Velocity weapon intended for the Cromwell.
Image
Tank, Cruiser, Comet l (A34)
With the A34 (the General Staff specification), later named Comet, the tank designers opted to correct some of the Cromwell's flaws in armament, track design and suspension while building upon its strengths of low height, high speed and mobility. This replaced the need for the Challenger and Firefly and acted upon the experiences gained through design and early deployment of the Cromwell.

Originally, it had been expected that the Cromwell would use the "High Velocity 75 mm" gun designed by Vickers but it would not fit into the turret. Development of the gun continued and as work commenced on the Comet, the gun design evolved into the 17 pdr HV (High Velocity). The gun now used the same calibre (76.2 mm) projectile as the 17-pounder but the cartridge case was from the older QF 3 inch 20 cwt anti-aircraft gun loaded to higher pressures. The resulting round was different from 17-pounder ammunition, being shorter, more compact and more easily stored and handled within the tank.
The 17 pdr HV was a shortened 17-pounder. This made it possible to mount the gun on a smaller turret ring. The gun was still capable against opponents and firing APDS rounds, more accurate and consistent than APDS from the 17-pounder and 6-pounder, which were inaccurate over 700m and often ricocheted. The Challenger turret had been so large to allow space for two loaders.

Several other improvements were made and many Cromwell design revisions were incorporated, such as safety hatches for the driver and hull gunner. The hull was fully welded as standard and armour was increased, ranging from 32 mm to 74 mm on the hull, while the turret was from 57 to 102 mm.
A new lower-profile welded turret was created using a cast gun mantlet for the 77 mm. The turret was electrically traversed (a design feature taken from the Churchill tank), with a generator powered by the main engine rather than the hydraulic system of the Cromwell. Ammunition for the 17 mm gun was stored in armoured bins.

The Comet's suspension was strengthened, and track return rollers were added. As with later Cromwells, the Comet tank's top speed was limited from the Cromwell's 40+ mph to a slower, but respectable 32 mph (51 km/h). This change preserved the lifespan of suspension and engine components and reduced track wear.

Similar to later Churchills, the Comet benefited from lessons learned in the co-operation of tanks with infantry. It was fitted as standard with two radio sets: a Wireless Set No. 19, for communication with the regiment and the troop, and a No. 38 Wireless for communication with infantry units. Like many British tanks, it also had a telephone handset mounted on the rear so that accompanying infantry could talk to the crew.
Image
Production
Comet tanks were built by a number of British firms led by Leyland, including English Electric, John Fowler & Co., and Metro-Cammell
The mild steel prototype was ready in February 1944 and entered trials. Concerns about the hull gunner and belly armour were put to one side to avoid redesign, but there was still sufficient delay caused by minor modifications and changes. Production models did not commence delivery until September 1944. The Comet was intended to be in service by December 1944, but crew training was delayed by the German Ardennes Offensive. By the end of the war, 1,200 had been produced.
Image
World War II Service History
The British 11th Armoured Division was the first formation to receive the new tanks, with deliveries commencing in December 1944 and the 29th Armoured Brigade, then equipped with Shermans, was withdrawn from fighting in the southern Netherlands early in the same month for re-equipping. After arriving in Brussels and preparing to hand in their Shermans the Ardennes Offensive commenced, and the brigade was forced to hastily take back its Shermans in order to take part in the countering of the German attack. The unit returned to the Brussels area in the middle of January 1945 three weeks later and finally paid-off its Shermans in exchange for Comets. The 11th Armoured would be the only division to be completely refitted with the Comet by the end of the war. The Comet saw combat and 26 were destroyed but due to its late arrival in the war in north west Europe, it did not participate in big battles. The Comet was involved in the crossing of the Rhine and the later Berlin Victory Parade in July 1945. The Comet's maximum speed of 32 miles per hour (51 km/h) was greatly exploited on the German Autobahn (motorways).


There's more information at the excellent Tanks Encyclopaedia: here

Onto the kit which has been lurking in my stash for a little while
Image

Here are the sprue frames - not a huge part count compared to some armour kits
Image

In the following shot there are two each of the wheels sprue & flexible track
Image

There were some aftermarket additions included in the kit I picked up: wheels, tracks, barrel & mantlet but not sure how much of this I'll use yet
Image

And finally the instruction book - some of which has instruction annotation only in (I think) Chinese... which may prove interesting
ImageImage

I've got something to finish off on the bench at the moment but hopefully I'll be able to get started soon. :cheers2:
Cheers, Neil

On the Bench:
Tamiya 1/35 PzKpfwIB
Tamiya 1/35 Willys Jeep
Revell 1/72 Millennium Falcon
User avatar
digger303
General
General
Posts: 15762
Joined: Mon Mar 16, 2015 10:01 am
Location: Western Australia
Australia

Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

Post by digger303 »

That's my comet :lol: :th: :cheers2:
Listen and appear wise
Image
Image

scalemates stash https://www.scalemates.com/profiles/mat ... ION[]=Kits
Image
robwuk
Master Sergeant
Master Sergeant
Posts: 358
Joined: Mon Jun 29, 2020 3:19 pm
England

Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

Post by robwuk »

looks a nice build... and nice additions
User avatar
Kevthemodeller
Lieutenant Colonel
Lieutenant Colonel
Posts: 5596
Joined: Sat Mar 26, 2016 8:31 am
Location: Newton Abbot UK
England

Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

Post by Kevthemodeller »

I've got a Bronco Comet in my stash too Neil, was only looking at it yesterday thinking the very same you've have :th:

Looking forward to seeing it come together mate :th:
Last edited by Kevthemodeller on Sat Oct 03, 2020 11:36 am, edited 1 time in total.
Kev

On the bench:
Border Model FOCKE-WULF W190A-8 R2 - 8
User avatar
aur0ra145
Second Lieutenant
Second Lieutenant
Posts: 3079
Joined: Thu Jan 14, 2016 9:44 am
Location: TX
United States of America

Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

Post by aur0ra145 »

This looks like a fun build!
User avatar
RangerNeil
Captain
Captain
Posts: 4279
Joined: Fri Jul 12, 2019 9:42 pm
Location: Dagenham
Contact:
Great Britain

Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

Post by RangerNeil »

Small factoid - the restored Comet in the photo was first seen at the Beltring W&P show in 2013 and followed my OT-90 into the arena. The OT-90, whilst unable to perform the true neutral turn most tracked armour is capable of, was more than capable of reversing direction at speed by simply stopping one track dead and spinning around the centre point of the dead track. At speed.... A guaranteed crowd pleaser. On this day the restored Comet following us tried to emulate us - and shed a track as per the comment in the historical data on the importance of track tension....
    Neil (yet another one...)

    On the board now:

    Airfix 1/35 Alvis Stalwart Mk2 FV622
    Airfix 1/72 Westland Wessex
    Mastercraft 1/72 Westland Wessex
    OKits 1/72 Mil Mi-2
    WNW Bristol F2B
    2 x Airfix Triumph TR4A

    Scalemates stash info
    =58417&fkSTASHSTATUS[]=58417-Stash&page=stash]Scalemates Stash manager
    User avatar
    Stokesy44
    Major General
    Major General
    Posts: 8232
    Joined: Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:13 am
    Location: The Midlands, UK
    Great Britain

    Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

    Post by Stokesy44 »

    Very nice looking kit. Like the extras too. How do the resin tracks work?
    Its been tried and tested, it works! So don't blame the system if you're no good. :doh:
    User avatar
    digger303
    General
    General
    Posts: 15762
    Joined: Mon Mar 16, 2015 10:01 am
    Location: Western Australia
    Australia

    Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

    Post by digger303 »

    Stokesy44 wrote: Fri Oct 02, 2020 11:34 pm Very nice looking kit. Like the extras too. How do the resin tracks work?
    I think you have to heat them in water to get them around the drives.
    Listen and appear wise
    Image
    Image

    scalemates stash https://www.scalemates.com/profiles/mat ... ION[]=Kits
    Image
    User avatar
    Stokesy44
    Major General
    Major General
    Posts: 8232
    Joined: Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:13 am
    Location: The Midlands, UK
    Great Britain

    Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

    Post by Stokesy44 »

    Cant believe us Brits actually managed to build a decent tank before the end of the war. A half decent hull with a 17 pounder in a turret you didn't need to be the size of an ewok to operate! :clap: :clap: :clap:

    Also, where did you get all that after market stuff?
    Its been tried and tested, it works! So don't blame the system if you're no good. :doh:
    User avatar
    Quax
    Sergeant Major of the Army
    Sergeant Major of the Army
    Posts: 1263
    Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2015 9:52 am
    Location: Andover, Hampshire
    England

    Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

    Post by Quax »

    Nice one Neil although it can't be considered a real tank as its missing 25 wheels... :lol:
    The sWS i built was a Bronco kit and went together ok with a few Dragony instructions so it will be interesting to see how it goes :pop:

    Paul
    Paul :hi: (not THE Paul a more inconsequential Paul)

    On the bench:
    A mess as usual...
    now residing in the Peoples Democratic Republic of Penguinland - long live the Emperor!
    User avatar
    Tomcat64
    Brigadier General
    Brigadier General
    Posts: 7034
    Joined: Thu Sep 22, 2016 3:24 pm
    Location: Swindon, UK
    England

    Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

    Post by Tomcat64 »

    digger303 wrote: Fri Oct 02, 2020 11:30 am That's my comet :lol: :th: :cheers2:
    Yup I snuck onto the farm and nicked it while you weren't looking :lol:
    robwuk wrote: Fri Oct 02, 2020 5:13 pm looks a nice build... and nice additions
    Cheers Rob - thanks for dropping in :th:
    Kevthemodeller wrote: Fri Oct 02, 2020 5:18 pm I've got a Bronco Comet in my stash too Neil, was only looking at it yesterday thinking the very same you've have :th:

    Looking forward to seeing it come together mate :th:
    I might have some leftover extras for you if you want them Kev - looks like I ended up with two sets of wheels somehow! Memo to self - check what's in the box before ordering stuff :oops:
    aur0ra145 wrote: Fri Oct 02, 2020 7:07 pm This looks like a fun build!
    Cheers mate :cheers2:
    RangerNeil wrote: Fri Oct 02, 2020 9:58 pm Small factoid - the restored Comet in the photo was first seen at the Beltring W&P show in 2013 and followed my OT-90 into the arena. The OT-90, whilst unable to perform the true neutral turn most tracked armour is capable of, was more than capable of reversing direction at speed by simply stopping one track dead and spinning around the centre point of the dead track. At speed.... A guaranteed crowd pleaser. On this day the restored Comet following us tried to emulate us - and shed a track as per the comment in the historical data on the importance of track tension....
    That's interesting about the tension on the tracks; I took that photo at Tankfest last year and when I was digging about for reference photos I had noticed that there seemed to be more slack in their tracks than in the wartime photos.
    digger303 wrote: Sat Oct 03, 2020 1:01 am
    Stokesy44 wrote: Fri Oct 02, 2020 11:34 pm Very nice looking kit. Like the extras too. How do the resin tracks work?
    I think you have to heat them in water to get them around the drives.
    Yeah - I think you're right and I'm not completely sold on the idea yet... given the lack of slack/sag involved I might just go with the rubber bands on this one... will make a final decision when I get to that part of the build...
    Stokesy44 wrote: Sat Oct 03, 2020 9:44 am Cant believe us Brits actually managed to build a decent tank before the end of the war. A half decent hull with a 17 pounder in a turret you didn't need to be the size of an ewok to operate! :clap: :clap: :clap:
    Image
    Image
    Stokesy44 wrote: Sat Oct 03, 2020 9:44 am Also, where did you get all that after market stuff?
    From memory I think most of what I bought came from Accurate Armour (Scottish company that does some decent resin bits)
    Quax wrote: Sat Oct 03, 2020 11:18 am Nice one Neil although it can't be considered a real tank as its missing 25 wheels... :lol:
    The sWS i built was a Bronco kit and went together ok with a few Dragony instructions so it will be interesting to see how it goes :pop:

    Paul
    Cheers Paul - the lack of wheels threw me there for a moment :lol: and the Chinese instructions are an interesting touch as well :th:
    Cheers, Neil

    On the Bench:
    Tamiya 1/35 PzKpfwIB
    Tamiya 1/35 Willys Jeep
    Revell 1/72 Millennium Falcon
    User avatar
    Tomcat64
    Brigadier General
    Brigadier General
    Posts: 7034
    Joined: Thu Sep 22, 2016 3:24 pm
    Location: Swindon, UK
    England

    Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet - Build Part I

    Post by Tomcat64 »

    I got this one underway this weekend. Just as a couple of quick notes on the overall quality of the kit: the plastic feels a little soft so care is needed when sanding as it's easy to overdo it; and there are a lot of EPMs scattered around, most of them are tucked away where they wont be seen but every so often one pops up and needs sanding off because it's either visible or fouling a contact point. Aside from that there are some minor mould seams and a little flash but nothing horrendous and the detailing is generally good :th:

    Here's the first page of the instructions dealing with the suspension and lower hull end plates
    Image

    The suspension on one side in place
    Image

    And the other side with the spaced armour in place as as well - the locating pins for this were a little snug so drilled them out to get an easier fit
    Image

    The only real notes here are that the towing shackles are a really loose fit and need to be held in place until the glue holds them
    Image

    I'm also not sure about the finish of the two halves of the spring section around the back so I'll check some reference photos and see if I need to fill that join or if it was a pair of leaf springs in actuality
    Image

    Page 2 adds the wheels so we'll skip that for now as they'll be added later
    Image

    Moving onto the upper hull here's a shot of the underside showing the extend of the EPMs mentioned earlier - most of these will be out of sight so not a real problem, but having done some testing a few of them foul the contact points with the lower hull so will need some attention
    Image

    Also it became obvious that there was some warpage to deal with at some point with the rear fenders; not sure if this is the casting or the way it's been stored.
    Image

    Down the back end and the engine access doors dropped in nicely, there are some gaps to deal with down the sides though (arrowed) where E7 & E25 didn't quite settle in properly. This should only take a swipe of putty to sort out on both sides so nothing major.
    Image

    At the front the location points for D27 are really insignificant so I added a drop of CA to try and aid adhesion, but still managed to ping one of them off later... I've no idea when so the chances of getting it back from the carpet monster are remote...
    Image

    Page3 continues the build up of the upper hull.
    Image

    One slight riddle here is that there is a part F34 and a part F34+1... ok... I was expecting them to be together on the F sprue frame, but nope - here they are arrowed
    Image

    And if you flip them over the tab arrowed here has a "1" on it to show which is which... what a bizarre way of doing it...
    Image

    Anyway here's the front detail installed... one other puzzle here is that there is no locating hole for the F49 & F16 assembly, this is easy enough to rectify with a quick drill out but having checked some references I can't see that on the photos I've looked at (or the box art for that matter) so I'll do a bit more digging on that one
    Image

    And finally for this update here's the upper & lower halves dry fitted. I discovered during this test fit that there is a slight warp to the upper hull (bow to stern) so I've changed my approach to the build sequence as I had planned to leave the two sections separate until after painting up; but given the access I'll need to get a decent join I'll join the upper & lower halves before installing the running gear. So I've carefully removed the front fender guards to allow this.
    Image

    That's all for now - aside from the mentioned niggles it's going together well and certainly seems to be the right shape so far.

    Thanks as always for looking :cheers2:
    Cheers, Neil

    On the Bench:
    Tamiya 1/35 PzKpfwIB
    Tamiya 1/35 Willys Jeep
    Revell 1/72 Millennium Falcon
    User avatar
    Stokesy44
    Major General
    Major General
    Posts: 8232
    Joined: Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:13 am
    Location: The Midlands, UK
    Great Britain

    Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

    Post by Stokesy44 »

    Looks a bit tricksy! You’ll knock her into shape though :bash:
    Its been tried and tested, it works! So don't blame the system if you're no good. :doh:
    User avatar
    RangerNeil
    Captain
    Captain
    Posts: 4279
    Joined: Fri Jul 12, 2019 9:42 pm
    Location: Dagenham
    Contact:
    Great Britain

    Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

    Post by RangerNeil »

    Nice job thus far!! :cheers2:
    Might be worth remembering that, for the E7/E25 issue, on AFV's panel fit isn't the same as on a car - large and small gaps can be the norm and gaps will vary from one vehicle to another - even on subsequent production vehicles. :)
      Neil (yet another one...)

      On the board now:

      Airfix 1/35 Alvis Stalwart Mk2 FV622
      Airfix 1/72 Westland Wessex
      Mastercraft 1/72 Westland Wessex
      OKits 1/72 Mil Mi-2
      WNW Bristol F2B
      2 x Airfix Triumph TR4A

      Scalemates stash info
      =58417&fkSTASHSTATUS[]=58417-Stash&page=stash]Scalemates Stash manager
      BigWall
      Chief Warrant Officer 5
      Chief Warrant Officer 5
      Posts: 2961
      Joined: Sun Mar 15, 2020 11:44 pm
      Location: Denver, Colorado
      United States of America

      Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

      Post by BigWall »

      Looks like you made some good progress and that the issues, at least, aren't major problems to overcome. Hopefully the deck straightens out for you when you fasten it down.
      Joe

      Image
      User avatar
      Tomcat64
      Brigadier General
      Brigadier General
      Posts: 7034
      Joined: Thu Sep 22, 2016 3:24 pm
      Location: Swindon, UK
      England

      Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

      Post by Tomcat64 »

      Stokesy44 wrote: Mon Oct 12, 2020 7:21 pm Looks a bit tricksy! You’ll knock her into shape though :bash:
      RangerNeil wrote: Mon Oct 12, 2020 9:24 pm Nice job thus far!! :cheers2:
      Might be worth remembering that, for the E7/E25 issue, on AFV's panel fit isn't the same as on a car - large and small gaps can be the norm and gaps will vary from one vehicle to another - even on subsequent production vehicles. :)
      BigWall wrote: Tue Oct 13, 2020 1:39 am Looks like you made some good progress and that the issues, at least, aren't major problems to overcome. Hopefully the deck straightens out for you when you fasten it down.
      Thanks guys - it's certainly thrown up a couple of quirks but nothing too major yet :)

      I've taken another look at the rear fenders and I think I should be able to use the rear mudguards to pull them into alignment - will let you know how I get on in the next update :th:
      Cheers, Neil

      On the Bench:
      Tamiya 1/35 PzKpfwIB
      Tamiya 1/35 Willys Jeep
      Revell 1/72 Millennium Falcon
      User avatar
      Tomcat64
      Brigadier General
      Brigadier General
      Posts: 7034
      Joined: Thu Sep 22, 2016 3:24 pm
      Location: Swindon, UK
      England

      Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet - Build Part II

      Post by Tomcat64 »

      I've had a couple of good sessions at the bench and moved this along well in the last week.

      Page 4 of the instructions covered the remainder of the hull front plus the gun breech.
      Image

      So I completed the former and skipped the latter since the turret will be buttoned up and the after market mantlet would make joining things up a little tricky. The only additional thing I did here was to drill out the bow machine gun muzzle
      Image

      I then decided to tackle joining the upper & lower hull... starting at the front and using strategically placed drops of CA; here's a side shot to show the deflection.
      Image

      This was left to cure overnight, and then I skipped forward to take a look at the construction on the back end including the rear mudguards which were added to the upper hull and also left to set
      Image Image

      Using more CA, the parts shown in the instructions above and gentle force I was able to get everything more or less lined up - again this was held in place with masking tape overnight to allow everything to cure properly. More TET was then run along the edges to try and help hold the bond - I've also added weights inside the hull as usual with my armour builds to give it some heft
      Image

      The final components were then added to the rear hull plate - as you can see there's still some tidying up to do around some of the joins but everything seems to be holding
      Image

      Attention then switched to the turret; in the following page I took the instructions arrowed in red to mean remove these bits since they're for the post war smoke launchers. Also there's a hole to drill out (orange instructions) but no locating pin on the associated light bracket so not sure if I missed something there
      Image Image

      Leaving off the mantlet and gun the rest of the turret went together pretty well
      Image

      I had a choice of three mantlets (original kit, resin replacement from the kit or Accurate Armour resin replacement) and three guns (original kit, resin from Accurate Armour or LionMarc turned metal) and in the end I settled on combining the Accurate Armour mantlet with the LionMarc barrel. I had to trim back the "chin" on the turret base to get the mantlet to settle properly, and I've used the kit machine gun drilled out and shortened as I wasn't happy with that feature on the AA mantlet - here's the result with everything in place
      Image

      And all installed on the hull
      Image

      Next up I'll make a start on the resin wheels and the final PE components for the hull & turret

      Thanks as always for looking :cheers2:
      Cheers, Neil

      On the Bench:
      Tamiya 1/35 PzKpfwIB
      Tamiya 1/35 Willys Jeep
      Revell 1/72 Millennium Falcon
      BigWall
      Chief Warrant Officer 5
      Chief Warrant Officer 5
      Posts: 2961
      Joined: Sun Mar 15, 2020 11:44 pm
      Location: Denver, Colorado
      United States of America

      Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

      Post by BigWall »

      Nice progress. That mantlet is going to look very nice once it's painted up.
      Joe

      Image
      User avatar
      Stokesy44
      Major General
      Major General
      Posts: 8232
      Joined: Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:13 am
      Location: The Midlands, UK
      Great Britain

      Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

      Post by Stokesy44 »

      Cracking build so far. Nice to see a British tank with a big honking HV gun on it!
      Its been tried and tested, it works! So don't blame the system if you're no good. :doh:
      User avatar
      LWWales
      First Sergeant
      First Sergeant
      Posts: 528
      Joined: Tue Apr 21, 2020 9:24 pm
      Wales

      Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

      Post by LWWales »

      Looking great mate! I love how detailed your posts are!
      Previously on the bench: Tamiya 1/20 McLaren MP4/4 - Top Studio super detail set.

      Current build: Tamiya 1/12 Honda VF750R & Hobby Design set
      User avatar
      digger303
      General
      General
      Posts: 15762
      Joined: Mon Mar 16, 2015 10:01 am
      Location: Western Australia
      Australia

      Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

      Post by digger303 »

      Nice, thanks for being point man on this. Now I must remember this post before I blindly charge into my comet in the distant future. Yeah I probably will ...damn my imperfect self.. :shock: :(
      As LWWales said great informative posts backed by great skills.
      :th: :th: :cheers2:
      Listen and appear wise
      Image
      Image

      scalemates stash https://www.scalemates.com/profiles/mat ... ION[]=Kits
      Image
      User avatar
      Stokesy44
      Major General
      Major General
      Posts: 8232
      Joined: Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:13 am
      Location: The Midlands, UK
      Great Britain

      Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

      Post by Stokesy44 »

      There’s very little in life that can’t be solved by CA glue and elbow grease!

      Once you find the product you like it becomes the go to option. There’s a problem with the kit? Don’t worry, I’ve just been to the store and have a plentiful supply of the magic juice!

      All is well :cheers2:
      Its been tried and tested, it works! So don't blame the system if you're no good. :doh:
      User avatar
      Tomcat64
      Brigadier General
      Brigadier General
      Posts: 7034
      Joined: Thu Sep 22, 2016 3:24 pm
      Location: Swindon, UK
      England

      Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

      Post by Tomcat64 »

      BigWall wrote: Sat Oct 17, 2020 4:57 pm Nice progress. That mantlet is going to look very nice once it's painted up.
      Stokesy44 wrote: Sat Oct 17, 2020 5:27 pm Cracking build so far. Nice to see a British tank with a big honking HV gun on it!
      LWWales wrote: Sat Oct 17, 2020 5:50 pm Looking great mate! I love how detailed your posts are!
      digger303 wrote: Sun Oct 18, 2020 1:24 am Nice, thanks for being point man on this. Now I must remember this post before I blindly charge into my comet in the distant future. Yeah I probably will ...damn my imperfect self.. :shock: :(
      As LWWales said great informative posts backed by great skills.
      :th: :th: :cheers2:
      Stokesy44 wrote: Sun Oct 18, 2020 9:07 am There’s very little in life that can’t be solved by CA glue and elbow grease!

      Once you find the product you like it becomes the go to option. There’s a problem with the kit? Don’t worry, I’ve just been to the store and have a plentiful supply of the magic juice!

      All is well :cheers2:
      Thanks guys :cheers2:

      Haven't found anything in this one yet that can't be fixed with lashings of CA :)
      Cheers, Neil

      On the Bench:
      Tamiya 1/35 PzKpfwIB
      Tamiya 1/35 Willys Jeep
      Revell 1/72 Millennium Falcon
      User avatar
      Tomcat64
      Brigadier General
      Brigadier General
      Posts: 7034
      Joined: Thu Sep 22, 2016 3:24 pm
      Location: Swindon, UK
      England

      Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet - Build Part III

      Post by Tomcat64 »

      I've had another good session at the bench this afternoon whilst Mrs Tomcat pottered in the garden :)

      First up I cut/sanded/built/sanded & test fitted/sanded the replacement resin return rollers - they did need a little tidying up but eventually got them lined up
      Image

      Onto the road wheels and they required the locating pins on the suspension arms to be removed (arrowed). As you can also see clearly here I decided not to bother cleaning up the EPMs under the fenders as they'll be out of sight when the build is finished
      Image

      I built up one of the kit wheels to try and get things aligned properly, and here you can see from left to right the kit wheelset, a replacement outer dry fitted and a replacement full set dry fitted. Once again the resin wheels did require some work to tidy up using the usual precautions for working with resin.
      Image

      The centres of most of the wheel shafts needed drilling out as well but eventually I managed to get everything dry fitted (more or less) to see what it'd look like. Also of note here is that the replacement WW2 idlers that come included in the kit seemed somewhat impervious to CA until I'd keyed the mating surfaces with a little light sanding, so not sure if there was some release agent that might need washing off in there somewhere.
      Image

      Ok... onto some fiddly stuff...
      Image

      Here's the instructions for the birdcage sight...
      Image

      And here's the part... they don't quite match, for those following along the highlighted cutaway should sit front left...
      Image

      I didn't spot this in the reference photos in time and had it folded the wrong way up, but here's the end result...
      Image

      Here's the reference photo I finally spotted :)
      Image

      And here's mine installed back to front :) Too late to do anything about it by then
      Image

      Right - down to the back end and I wanted to install the twin exhaust covers rather than the single one purely for visual interest
      Image

      With the first one I attached the end plate to the curved sheet (this was curved around the original piece and a finger) and then attached it to the hull prior to installing the second end plate... this worked ok, but not as well as the second attempt
      Image

      For the second one I installed the two end plates onto the hull first and then installed the curved cover over the top... this worked much better
      Image

      Also whilst I was pondering this I spotted a couple of additional plates on the PE... part number 4
      Image

      Back to the references and they're attached to the rear hull plate... no mention of these little blighters in the instructions that I could see though :)
      Image

      So here they are along with the completed Exhaust covers all in place
      Image

      So I think that's the main build done... I'll leave everything to settle & cure and then work around filling any obvious gaps and doing final cleanup before embarking on primer. I'll also have a final check to make sure I've not missed anything else from the parts that might not be in the instructions :)

      Thanks as always for looking & commenting - it's always very much appreciated :cheers2:
      Cheers, Neil

      On the Bench:
      Tamiya 1/35 PzKpfwIB
      Tamiya 1/35 Willys Jeep
      Revell 1/72 Millennium Falcon
      User avatar
      Stokesy44
      Major General
      Major General
      Posts: 8232
      Joined: Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:13 am
      Location: The Midlands, UK
      Great Britain

      Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

      Post by Stokesy44 »

      Cracking work. Those resin wheels look great and the PE looks well worth the effort.
      Its been tried and tested, it works! So don't blame the system if you're no good. :doh:
      User avatar
      RangerNeil
      Captain
      Captain
      Posts: 4279
      Joined: Fri Jul 12, 2019 9:42 pm
      Location: Dagenham
      Contact:
      Great Britain

      Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

      Post by RangerNeil »

      The turret with the alternate mantlet and gun barrel really looks the part, Well done!! :cheers2:
        Neil (yet another one...)

        On the board now:

        Airfix 1/35 Alvis Stalwart Mk2 FV622
        Airfix 1/72 Westland Wessex
        Mastercraft 1/72 Westland Wessex
        OKits 1/72 Mil Mi-2
        WNW Bristol F2B
        2 x Airfix Triumph TR4A

        Scalemates stash info
        =58417&fkSTASHSTATUS[]=58417-Stash&page=stash]Scalemates Stash manager
        BigWall
        Chief Warrant Officer 5
        Chief Warrant Officer 5
        Posts: 2961
        Joined: Sun Mar 15, 2020 11:44 pm
        Location: Denver, Colorado
        United States of America

        Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

        Post by BigWall »

        Very nicely built! I can't wait to see the paint go down.
        Joe

        Image
        User avatar
        digger303
        General
        General
        Posts: 15762
        Joined: Mon Mar 16, 2015 10:01 am
        Location: Western Australia
        Australia

        Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

        Post by digger303 »

        It's a bugger when you realize a mistake and can't retify it cause it will destroy the part. Are there some bolt heads on the sprue to go on the square plates which you found had to be attached on the rear plate ?
        Can't wait for you to get the tracks on.
        :th: :th: :cheers2:
        Listen and appear wise
        Image
        Image

        scalemates stash https://www.scalemates.com/profiles/mat ... ION[]=Kits
        Image
        User avatar
        Kevthemodeller
        Lieutenant Colonel
        Lieutenant Colonel
        Posts: 5596
        Joined: Sat Mar 26, 2016 8:31 am
        Location: Newton Abbot UK
        England

        Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

        Post by Kevthemodeller »

        Tomcat64 wrote: Mon Oct 12, 2020 2:23 pm I might have some leftover extras for you if you want them Kev - looks like I ended up with two sets of wheels somehow! Memo to self - check what's in the box before ordering stuff :oops:
        Thanks Neil I'll bear that in mind mate :th:

        I'm working on a F100 Super Sabre (off line at the moment) work has come returned with a vengeance :wtf:

        Not had a lot of time to post and just wanted to enjoy the build without pressure of recording everything. That said things are starting to quieten down a little and back to more normal levels, so may post a part build, or just go for reveal, we'll see. The Comet is coming on a treat, lovely PE work there mate :th: My old next door neighbor, sadly died some years ago now. Was 11th Armour Div and was one of the first units to get the Comet and use them in action. He had some truly amazing pictures, having been in Shermas before he said they were a game changing tank :thumb1:
        Kev

        On the bench:
        Border Model FOCKE-WULF W190A-8 R2 - 8
        User avatar
        Stokesy44
        Major General
        Major General
        Posts: 8232
        Joined: Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:13 am
        Location: The Midlands, UK
        Great Britain

        Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

        Post by Stokesy44 »

        Kevthemodeller wrote: Mon Oct 19, 2020 8:31 am
        Tomcat64 wrote: Mon Oct 12, 2020 2:23 pm I might have some leftover extras for you if you want them Kev - looks like I ended up with two sets of wheels somehow! Memo to self - check what's in the box before ordering stuff :oops:
        Thanks Neil I'll bear that in mind mate :th:

        I'm working on a F100 Super Sabre (off line at the moment) work has come returned with a vengeance :wtf:

        Not had a lot of time to post and just wanted to enjoy the build without pressure of recording everything. That said things are starting to quieten down a little and back to more normal levels, so may post a part build, or just go for reveal, we'll see. The Comet is coming on a treat, lovely PE work there mate :th: My old next door neighbor, sadly died some years ago now. Was 11th Armour Div and was one of the first units to get the Comet and use them in action. He had some truly amazing pictures, having been in Shermas before he said they were a game changing tank :thumb1:
        It is still surprising to me that for all of WW2, the British lacked behind in tank design. They excelled in nearly every other design area but they never came up with a tank their crews were happy with, right up until the Comet.
        Its been tried and tested, it works! So don't blame the system if you're no good. :doh:
        User avatar
        Tomcat64
        Brigadier General
        Brigadier General
        Posts: 7034
        Joined: Thu Sep 22, 2016 3:24 pm
        Location: Swindon, UK
        England

        Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

        Post by Tomcat64 »

        Stokesy44 wrote: Sun Oct 18, 2020 5:51 pm Cracking work. Those resin wheels look great and the PE looks well worth the effort.
        RangerNeil wrote: Sun Oct 18, 2020 9:53 pm The turret with the alternate mantlet and gun barrel really looks the part, Well done!! :cheers2:
        BigWall wrote: Sun Oct 18, 2020 11:36 pm Very nicely built! I can't wait to see the paint go down.
        Thanks guys! :cheers2:
        digger303 wrote: Mon Oct 19, 2020 12:42 am It's a bugger when you realize a mistake and can't retify it cause it will destroy the part. Are there some bolt heads on the sprue to go on the square plates which you found had to be attached on the rear plate ?
        Can't wait for you to get the tracks on.
        :th: :th: :cheers2:
        The bolt heads are actually raised on the PE plates, it just looks like indentations the way the light is reflecting in the photos :)
        Kevthemodeller wrote: Mon Oct 19, 2020 8:31 am
        Tomcat64 wrote: Mon Oct 12, 2020 2:23 pm I might have some leftover extras for you if you want them Kev - looks like I ended up with two sets of wheels somehow! Memo to self - check what's in the box before ordering stuff :oops:
        Thanks Neil I'll bear that in mind mate :th:

        I'm working on a F100 Super Sabre (off line at the moment) work has come returned with a vengeance :wtf:

        Not had a lot of time to post and just wanted to enjoy the build without pressure of recording everything. That said things are starting to quieten down a little and back to more normal levels, so may post a part build, or just go for reveal, we'll see. The Comet is coming on a treat, lovely PE work there mate :th: My old next door neighbor, sadly died some years ago now. Was 11th Armour Div and was one of the first units to get the Comet and use them in action. He had some truly amazing pictures, having been in Shermas before he said they were a game changing tank :thumb1:
        Cheers Kev - I'll keep hold of the wheels for you if you decide you want them :)

        I bet your old neighbour had some cracking stories to go along with those photos too!
        Stokesy44 wrote: Sun Oct 25, 2020 1:39 pm
        Kevthemodeller wrote: Mon Oct 19, 2020 8:31 am
        Tomcat64 wrote: Mon Oct 12, 2020 2:23 pm I might have some leftover extras for you if you want them Kev - looks like I ended up with two sets of wheels somehow! Memo to self - check what's in the box before ordering stuff :oops:
        Thanks Neil I'll bear that in mind mate :th:

        I'm working on a F100 Super Sabre (off line at the moment) work has come returned with a vengeance :wtf:

        Not had a lot of time to post and just wanted to enjoy the build without pressure of recording everything. That said things are starting to quieten down a little and back to more normal levels, so may post a part build, or just go for reveal, we'll see. The Comet is coming on a treat, lovely PE work there mate :th: My old next door neighbor, sadly died some years ago now. Was 11th Armour Div and was one of the first units to get the Comet and use them in action. He had some truly amazing pictures, having been in Shermas before he said they were a game changing tank :thumb1:
        It is still surprising to me that for all of WW2, the British lacked behind in tank design. They excelled in nearly every other design area but they never came up with a tank their crews were happy with, right up until the Comet.
        Yeah it's interesting isn't it - I get the feeling that the brass in the army retained their "we know best" attitude around tank design even in the face of practicality like fitting the gun on the Firefly for example. Maybe a throwback to "The Old Gang" approach?
        Cheers, Neil

        On the Bench:
        Tamiya 1/35 PzKpfwIB
        Tamiya 1/35 Willys Jeep
        Revell 1/72 Millennium Falcon
        User avatar
        Tomcat64
        Brigadier General
        Brigadier General
        Posts: 7034
        Joined: Thu Sep 22, 2016 3:24 pm
        Location: Swindon, UK
        England

        Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet - Build Part IV

        Post by Tomcat64 »

        I made a little more progress this weekend.

        After looking at some of the reference photos I decided to add a little scratch building down the back end - I'll also be adding stowage from various sets later on
        Image

        I also notice the struts in the twin exhaust cowlings that Bronco missed in their instructions (although they were included for the single piece fitting)
        Image

        After tidying up the joins it was time for some Ultimate primer to produce stealth comet... then more sanding where I'd missed some before repriming :)
        Image

        Comets were painted in British Olive Drab (SCC15) and the consensus is that Vallejo 71020 is the closest fit in their range for this... slightly ironically this was originally named "German Green" before being changed to "Green Brown"...anyway - here it is after a couple of coats
        Image

        The roadwheels also received some attention with NATO black used for the tyres
        Image

        And here they are dry fitted to see how it all looks at the moment
        Image

        Next up will be the completion of the return rollers & idlers as well as doing some modulation to break up the overall greenness. Oh and I need to do something with the tracks too I guess :)

        Thanks as always for looking :cheers2:
        Cheers, Neil

        On the Bench:
        Tamiya 1/35 PzKpfwIB
        Tamiya 1/35 Willys Jeep
        Revell 1/72 Millennium Falcon
        User avatar
        Kevthemodeller
        Lieutenant Colonel
        Lieutenant Colonel
        Posts: 5596
        Joined: Sat Mar 26, 2016 8:31 am
        Location: Newton Abbot UK
        England

        Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

        Post by Kevthemodeller »

        Tomcat64 wrote: Mon Oct 26, 2020 2:15 pm
        Cheers Kev - I'll keep hold of the wheels for you if you decide you want them :)
        Thanks mate very kind of you and much appreciated :th:
        Tomcat64 wrote: Mon Oct 26, 2020 2:15 pm I bet your old neighbour had some cracking stories to go along with those photos too!
        He most certainly did, he was in every major engagement from Normandy until he was wounded during Goodwood, he was a gunner, lost 3 Sherman's 2 in one day! The third at Goodwood was when he got wounded, got hit trying to get the commander out of the turret and over the back of the tank. Lucky it wasn't too bad, if you can call 'getting shot' not too bad! He was out for about 3 months I think he said. They were retraining on the Comet Nov- Dec 44, but got rushed to the Ardennes and put back in Shermans. They finally got the Comet in mid Jan, no real battles, lots of small actions pockets of Germans, until they crossed the Rhine, were the fighting resumed but didn't last long. He had some truly amazing pictures of Panthers, StuGs, Hetzers, Tiger II, just about all the major German armour. The Comet gun could knock them all out, he said some took a bit of maneuvering to get to kill shot. He said the most feared was infantry mainly Hitler Youth with Panzerfaust!
        Tomcat64 wrote: Mon Oct 26, 2020 2:15 pm Yeah it's interesting isn't it - I get the feeling that the brass in the army retained their "we know best" attitude around tank design even in the face of practicality like fitting the gun on the Firefly for example. Maybe a throwback to "The Old Gang" approach?
        I Think you're right mate problem goes back to before the war and the cuts of the 30's, bit like what we're doing all over again!
        Last edited by Kevthemodeller on Tue Oct 27, 2020 8:30 am, edited 1 time in total.
        Kev

        On the bench:
        Border Model FOCKE-WULF W190A-8 R2 - 8
        BigWall
        Chief Warrant Officer 5
        Chief Warrant Officer 5
        Posts: 2961
        Joined: Sun Mar 15, 2020 11:44 pm
        Location: Denver, Colorado
        United States of America

        Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

        Post by BigWall »

        She's coming along very nicely! Keep up the great work
        Joe

        Image
        User avatar
        digger303
        General
        General
        Posts: 15762
        Joined: Mon Mar 16, 2015 10:01 am
        Location: Western Australia
        Australia

        Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

        Post by digger303 »

        really smooth paint job :th: :th:
        Loved a bit of real history
        :th: :th: :cheers2:
        Listen and appear wise
        Image
        Image

        scalemates stash https://www.scalemates.com/profiles/mat ... ION[]=Kits
        Image
        Parker
        First Sergeant
        First Sergeant
        Posts: 545
        Joined: Tue May 19, 2020 6:49 am
        Location: Melbourne
        Australia

        Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

        Post by Parker »

        That's looking great.
        Anything with a back story is always captivating. It gives it meaning.
        Sadly those stories will soon become second hand.

        ...

        A bit off topic, but I would encourage all the dads, grandads, great grandads (I'm sure there's a few) on this forum, perhaps great great grandads !... to share their stories to their kids. Is so important.
        On The Bench (Dining Table) - CF-104 Starfighter

        Image
        User avatar
        Stokesy44
        Major General
        Major General
        Posts: 8232
        Joined: Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:13 am
        Location: The Midlands, UK
        Great Britain

        Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

        Post by Stokesy44 »

        That's a cracking paint job there Sir. Looking forward to see how you modulate that colour. I'll be doing the same on the Firefly so I'll be hoping to emulate (steal, nick, copy) your methods. :th: :th:
        Its been tried and tested, it works! So don't blame the system if you're no good. :doh:
        ForeverPlasticKits
        Command Sergeant Major
        Command Sergeant Major
        Posts: 895
        Joined: Wed Oct 21, 2020 8:45 pm
        Location: France
        France

        Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

        Post by ForeverPlasticKits »

        Definitively the Comet is my favorite english tank of WW2, your Bronco model is so amazing, and the add ons give it such a level of details ... :jd: :thumb1:
        User avatar
        RangerNeil
        Captain
        Captain
        Posts: 4279
        Joined: Fri Jul 12, 2019 9:42 pm
        Location: Dagenham
        Contact:
        Great Britain

        Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

        Post by RangerNeil »

        Kevthemodeller wrote: Mon Oct 26, 2020 6:02 pm
        <snipped>
        I Think you're right mate problem goes back to before the war and the cuts of the 30's, bit like what we're doing all over again!
        Start of the war the problem was middle and senior ranks being hidebound and conservative, clinging to ideas from WW1 if not earlier. Despite seeing what Germany was doing with armour - and the Soviets - they blindly insisted on the concept of the VERY slow moving infantry tank like the Matilda. It wasn't until later - around 42/43 after the worst had been replaced by officers with experience that the idea of fast moving heavy hitting tanks was allowed to flourish. Of course the actual design of them - using rivets instead of welds and unreliable engines is a different story. My old man used to say the most hated words in the Army at that time were "it was good enough then so its good enough now". Times change - rapidly in war - and ideas need to change too.Sadly ideas do not change anywhere near as rapidly where needed. Even though tank design flourished as inarguable (esp. after the Soviets rolled JS3's through Berlin in the victory parade) the Cheifs of Staff were so fixated on Victorian drill & formality they were clamouring for the disbandment of the SAS before the ink on the Nuremburg trial documents dried.
        These day the military has the flexibility of thought required but are hamstrung by Politicians who do not.

        But this digresses - the build is coming on amazingly well. Looking forwards to seeing the completed item. :) :)
          Neil (yet another one...)

          On the board now:

          Airfix 1/35 Alvis Stalwart Mk2 FV622
          Airfix 1/72 Westland Wessex
          Mastercraft 1/72 Westland Wessex
          OKits 1/72 Mil Mi-2
          WNW Bristol F2B
          2 x Airfix Triumph TR4A

          Scalemates stash info
          =58417&fkSTASHSTATUS[]=58417-Stash&page=stash]Scalemates Stash manager
          User avatar
          digger303
          General
          General
          Posts: 15762
          Joined: Mon Mar 16, 2015 10:01 am
          Location: Western Australia
          Australia

          Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

          Post by digger303 »

          RangerNeil wrote: Wed Oct 28, 2020 11:14 am
          Kevthemodeller wrote: Mon Oct 26, 2020 6:02 pm
          <snipped>
          I Think you're right mate problem goes back to before the war and the cuts of the 30's, bit like what we're doing all over again!
          Start of the war the problem was middle and senior ranks being hidebound and conservative, clinging to ideas from WW1 if not earlier. Despite seeing what Germany was doing with armour - and the Soviets - they blindly insisted on the concept of the VERY slow moving infantry tank like the Matilda. It wasn't until later - around 42/43 after the worst had been replaced by officers with experience that the idea of fast moving heavy hitting tanks was allowed to flourish. Of course the actual design of them - using rivets instead of welds and unreliable engines is a different story. My old man used to say the most hated words in the Army at that time were "it was good enough then so its good enough now". Times change - rapidly in war - and ideas need to change too.Sadly ideas do not change anywhere near as rapidly where needed. Even though tank design flourished as inarguable (esp. after the Soviets rolled JS3's through Berlin in the victory parade) the Cheifs of Staff were so fixated on Victorian drill & formality they were clamouring for the disbandment of the SAS before the ink on the Nuremburg trial documents dried.
          These day the military has the flexibility of thought required but are hamstrung by Politicians who do not.

          But this digresses - the build is coming on amazingly well. Looking forwards to seeing the completed item. :) :)
          Good thoughts :th: :th: :cheers2:
          Listen and appear wise
          Image
          Image

          scalemates stash https://www.scalemates.com/profiles/mat ... ION[]=Kits
          Image
          User avatar
          Quax
          Sergeant Major of the Army
          Sergeant Major of the Army
          Posts: 1263
          Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2015 9:52 am
          Location: Andover, Hampshire
          England

          Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

          Post by Quax »

          Stokesy44 wrote: Tue Oct 27, 2020 8:21 am That's a cracking paint job there Sir. Looking forward to see how you modulate that colour. I'll be doing the same on the Firefly so I'll be hoping to emulate (steal, nick, copy) your methods. :th: :th:

          my thoughts exactly! :thumb1: The kit has come together really well and I'm enjoying following! :clap: :clap:

          Paul
          Paul :hi: (not THE Paul a more inconsequential Paul)

          On the bench:
          A mess as usual...
          now residing in the Peoples Democratic Republic of Penguinland - long live the Emperor!
          User avatar
          digger303
          General
          General
          Posts: 15762
          Joined: Mon Mar 16, 2015 10:01 am
          Location: Western Australia
          Australia

          Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

          Post by digger303 »

          Quax wrote: Wed Oct 28, 2020 1:51 pm
          Stokesy44 wrote: Tue Oct 27, 2020 8:21 am That's a cracking paint job there Sir. Looking forward to see how you modulate that colour. I'll be doing the same on the Firefly so I'll be hoping to emulate (steal, nick, copy) your methods. :th: :th:

          my thoughts exactly! :thumb1: The kit has come together really well and I'm enjoying following! :clap: :clap:

          Paul
          :th: :th: :cheers2:
          Listen and appear wise
          Image
          Image

          scalemates stash https://www.scalemates.com/profiles/mat ... ION[]=Kits
          Image
          User avatar
          Kevthemodeller
          Lieutenant Colonel
          Lieutenant Colonel
          Posts: 5596
          Joined: Sat Mar 26, 2016 8:31 am
          Location: Newton Abbot UK
          England

          Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

          Post by Kevthemodeller »

          Neil, I hope you don't mind me hijacking your thread a little, but it is relevant and contains some corrections to and some further information of my once good friend who served in Comets, that I mentioned earlier. If you wish me to remove it, I of course will and won't be offended should you so wish it removed. As you know I moved house a year ago and after the normal, redecorating, alterations etc people do when moving into a new house, it takes a little while to get straight. We had a few things that weren't completed when Covid hit which meant some being delayed until a few weeks ago, which had prevented me from unpacking a fair bit of my belongings namely, modelling stash and reference material etc. This morning I found my friend 'Iolo Lewis' book, yes he wrote a book about himself, which details his wartime experiences in great detail, the book is called 'Time's Long Shadows' he was also a keen poet, the book contains them too.
          Image
          The corrections I need to make are, he was a wireless operator/loader not a gunner and he was wounded twice not once, in Normandy in 44 and Germany in Apr 45 after the Rhine crossing not during Goodwood. He lost 2 sherman's not 3, but he did lose 3 tanks, the last was a Comet hit by Panzerfaust as they entered the little village of Levern.
          My book was the second book he took out of the box after they were delivered and he signed it for me
          Image
          This is Iolo as he was in Sept 44
          Image
          When he was rushed to the Ardennes and back into Shermans in Dec 44, they picked them up from near Hougoumont on the Waterloo Battlefield. He was put in a Firefly, Iolo is the short one with his hands in his pockets, his said most loaders for the Firefly's had to be small as there's very little room to move in the loaders position.
          Image

          Here are a couple of his unit 3 RTR in action with Comets. The following pictures are in the book and are official ones taken by attached camera men. I saw all of the stamps on the back of the pictures and they are as stated in the book, I've seen them often used by others in publications and given the wrong dates and places.
          Image

          Image

          He said the shells on the Firefly were longer as the Comet didn't have the same gun. The Comet had the 17pdr HV which was shorter than the version in the Firefly and use ammunition with the shorter 3inch AA case.
          Image
          Image
          As you know the war in Europe ended in May, in July he was retaining in sherman DD's ready for the invasion of Japan, while doing so in Aug the A bombs were dropped and the war ended. Here is Iolo sitting on top of a DD.
          Image
          An example of his poetry, one of many in the book.
          It describes his last wounding when baling out of his Comet after being hit by Panzerfaust in Levern. He was hit in the thigh by rounds fired from others in the village, luckily and he swore it shaved his life he put the magazine from his sten in his pocket. He said trying to get out with it on the weapon was a real fuff as it caught on the hatch.
          Image
          This is how I like to remember him, taken in June 2000 on the unveiling of the RTR memorial in Whitehall London.
          Image
          Iolo sadly died in 2007, a lovely man and my friend. RIP and thank you Iolo
          Kev

          On the bench:
          Border Model FOCKE-WULF W190A-8 R2 - 8
          User avatar
          Stokesy44
          Major General
          Major General
          Posts: 8232
          Joined: Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:13 am
          Location: The Midlands, UK
          Great Britain

          Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

          Post by Stokesy44 »

          Fantastic post Kev. I’m sure Neil will love it’s I did
          Its been tried and tested, it works! So don't blame the system if you're no good. :doh:
          User avatar
          RangerNeil
          Captain
          Captain
          Posts: 4279
          Joined: Fri Jul 12, 2019 9:42 pm
          Location: Dagenham
          Contact:
          Great Britain

          Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

          Post by RangerNeil »

          This Neil certainly did!! :cheers2:
            Neil (yet another one...)

            On the board now:

            Airfix 1/35 Alvis Stalwart Mk2 FV622
            Airfix 1/72 Westland Wessex
            Mastercraft 1/72 Westland Wessex
            OKits 1/72 Mil Mi-2
            WNW Bristol F2B
            2 x Airfix Triumph TR4A

            Scalemates stash info
            =58417&fkSTASHSTATUS[]=58417-Stash&page=stash]Scalemates Stash manager
            BigWall
            Chief Warrant Officer 5
            Chief Warrant Officer 5
            Posts: 2961
            Joined: Sun Mar 15, 2020 11:44 pm
            Location: Denver, Colorado
            United States of America

            Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

            Post by BigWall »

            So cool!

            That's the Fehrmann tiger F01!

            This is taken from Reddit:

            They (The Fehrmann group) were made up of old revitalized tanks from a tank school and their commanders. Made up of around 6 tigers, 5 panthers and 2 half tracks. The last surviving Tiger was the F01 (picture above). It was damaged by a PIAT early on but was sent back for repairs in the tank school's workshop. Now commanded by Unteroffizier Franzen, the Tiger F01 went back to the front and slugged it out with the British Comets. Franzen and his crew managed to knock out a couple of Comets before their tank was disabled. All of the Tiger F01 crews were able to escape back to the tank school.

            Here's some pics from the web:

            ImageF01a by Big Wall, on Flickr

            ImageF01b by Big Wall, on Flickr

            ImageF01c by Big Wall, on Flickr

            ImageF01d by Big Wall, on Flickr

            ImageF01e by Big Wall, on Flickr

            One of my next builds is going to be tiger F13 from the Fehrmann group so I've been doing some reading up on them.

            That book is an absolute gem! I wish my grandfather had done something similar. He was in some of the worst battles. He wouldn't talk about any of his experiences though. I can't say I blame him.
            Joe

            Image
            User avatar
            digger303
            General
            General
            Posts: 15762
            Joined: Mon Mar 16, 2015 10:01 am
            Location: Western Australia
            Australia

            Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

            Post by digger303 »

            Good post :th: :th: :cheers2:
            Listen and appear wise
            Image
            Image

            scalemates stash https://www.scalemates.com/profiles/mat ... ION[]=Kits
            Image
            User avatar
            Rugash
            Sergeant
            Sergeant
            Posts: 127
            Joined: Tue Aug 18, 2020 9:36 am
            Location: NSW Australia
            Australia

            Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

            Post by Rugash »

            The build is coming along really nicely Tomcat, great work on the paint and the after market parts make look great. :th:

            I've found the same with some colours for Allied equipment that the closest colour is a German colour at times
            User avatar
            Tomcat64
            Brigadier General
            Brigadier General
            Posts: 7034
            Joined: Thu Sep 22, 2016 3:24 pm
            Location: Swindon, UK
            England

            Re: Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet

            Post by Tomcat64 »

            Thanks to everyone for checking in - sorry there's not any progress at the moment, hoping to get back to the bench this weekend.

            @Kevthemodeller & @BigWall thanks for all that information - it's fascinating stuff and feel free to post as much of it as you like anytime :th:

            Kev - if you've got any more reference photos of the Comet in there and get chance I'd love to see them - especially if they've got stowage on the rear decks or netting over the turret like the one you shared already :)
            Cheers, Neil

            On the Bench:
            Tamiya 1/35 PzKpfwIB
            Tamiya 1/35 Willys Jeep
            Revell 1/72 Millennium Falcon
            User avatar
            Tomcat64
            Brigadier General
            Brigadier General
            Posts: 7034
            Joined: Thu Sep 22, 2016 3:24 pm
            Location: Swindon, UK
            England

            Tomcat's 1/35 Bronco A34 Comet - Build Part V

            Post by Tomcat64 »

            Having been bogged down in other stuff the past few weeks I finally got the time & inclination to get back into the den this week and make enough progress for a quick update...

            First up the tracks... I decided that the resin chunks just looked too much like hard work so went for the kit rubber bands (I might use some of the resin bits for spare links on the turret/hull later). The bands were primed in Ultimate black followed by Vallejo Burnt Iron.

            The connection points (arrowed) were pretty much useless though...
            Image

            So working on the theory that the joins could be hidden behind the fenders I used some short lengths of brass wire to ack as "staples"
            Image

            The undersides were a little rougher but they later received a coat of very dark grey so that any shiny was disguised
            Image

            With the bands done I then attached the wheels in the following stages... first the drive sprockets (these were very tight and the teeth are really sharp so be warned!), followed by the resin idlers with CA. The tracks were then added at this point and I then worked along the return rollers followed by the road wheels from the centre positions outwards - due to the modifications required to get the resin set in place all the wheels had to be held with CA
            Image

            Finally the side fender panels were added and here's everything in place
            Image

            I've also drilled out the searchlight lens on the turret as I wasn't happy with the plastic version and remembered I had some 4mm lenses in the accessories & assorted junk bin which fit perfectly. I've also got some stowage to play with but next up will be to finish the paintwork, add the decals and do the initial weathering.

            That's all for now, but hopefully it won't be so long before the next update.

            Thanks as always for looking :cheers2:
            Cheers, Neil

            On the Bench:
            Tamiya 1/35 PzKpfwIB
            Tamiya 1/35 Willys Jeep
            Revell 1/72 Millennium Falcon
            Post Reply

            Return to “Build threads”